Largest Retail Property Sales on Long Island

Exterior of 403-405 Main St, Port Washington, NY

1. Freestanding Retail in Port Washington, NY
Address: 403-405 Main St, Port Washington, NY 11050
Sale Date: December 2, 2025
Sale Price: $8,700,000
PSF: $139

Ventura Marina Management Corp sold this freestanding retail building in Port Washington, NY to Manhasset Bay Real Estate LLC.

This building consists of 62,324 square-feet, is one story tall, and was built in 1956. This property has 64 ft of frontage on Main St with one curb cut and 50 on-site parking spaces.

This property has Manhasset Bay located behind the building and it is located within 1 mile from the Port Washington LIRR train station. The North Hempstead Town Dock and Sunset Park are located North of the property, within walking distance.

2. Storefront Retail in Babylon, NY
Address: 238-240 Deer Park Ave, Babylon, NY 11702
Sale Date: December 19, 2025
Sale Price: $4,625,000
Price/SF: $342

240 Deer Park Ave LLC sold this storefront retail building in Babylon, NY to an undisclosed buyer. The property reportedly traded at a 6.43% cap rate.

This building consists of 13,500 square-feet, is three stories tall, and was built in 1905. The property has 95 ft of frontage on Railroad Ave and there are 14 on-site parking spaces.

This property is located steps away from the Babylon LIRR train station as well as from several other major retail spaces on Deer Park Ave. This property is located North of Montauk Hwy and West of the Babylon Northport Expy.

Exterior of 238-240 Deer Park Ave, Babylon, NY

3. Restaurant in Southampton, NY
Address: 70 Main St, Southampton, NY 11968
Sale Date: December 10, 2025
Sale Price: $4,600,000
Price/SF: $1,108

Friedberg Family Limited sold this restaurant in Southampton, NY to an undisclosed buyer.

This restaurant consists of 4,150 square-feet, is two stories tall, and was built in 1980. It has a wide frontage on Main St of 131 ft and the building sits on 0.08 acres of land.

This property is located in the heart of Southampton surrounded by several neighborhood retail spaces and amenities. It is also located 0.7 miles away from the Southampton LIRR train station and a short distance from the Southampton Bypass.

Exterior of 70 Main St, Southampton, NY

4. Storefront Retail in Port Washington, NY
Address: 35-41 Main St, Port Washington, NY 11050
Sale Date: October 17, 2025
Sale Price: $4,450,000
Price/SF: $350

3541 Washington Realty LLC sold this storefront retail building in Port Washington, NY to Jets Cm Group LLC. The property reportedly traded at a 8.36% cap rate.

This building consists of 12,700 square-feet, is one story tall, was built in 1946 and later renovated in 2020. This property has 40 ft of frontage on Main St and there are surface parking spaces available at this location.

This property is surrounded by various other retail spaces such as restaurants, banks, coffee shops, and more. It is located within walking distance to the Port Washington LIRR train station and is a short distance from the Harbor Links Golf Course.

Exterior of 35-41 Main St, Port Washington, NY

5. Freestanding Retail in East Northport, NY
Address: 1900 Jericho Tpke, East Northport, NY 11731
Sale Date: December 8, 2025
Sale Price: $3,700,000
Price/SF: $302

Future Realty Corp sold this freestanding retail building in East Northport, NY to an undisclosed buyer.

This building consists of 12,225 square-feet, is one story tall, and was built in 1992. The property has 159 ft of frontage on Jericho Tpke with one curb cut. There are 74 on-site parking spaces and Jericho Tpke receives high daily traffic counts of 29,658 cars per day.

This property is surrounded by other retail spaces such as restaurants, clothing stores, shoe stores, and more. This property is located North of the Northern State Pkwy and the Long Island Expy.

Exterior of 1900 Jericho Tpke, East Northport, NY

6. Freestanding Retail in Baldwin, NY
Address: 1235 Grand Ave, Baldwin, NY 11510
Sale Date: October 30, 2025
Sale Price: $3,600,000
Price/SF: $798

Rdc Baldwin LLC sold this freestanding retail bank in Baldwin, NY to Hermes Management LLC.

This bank consists of 4,506 square-feet, is one story tall, was built in 1979, and renovated in 1994. There are 42 on-site parking spaces and this building sits on 1.09 acres of land.

This property is surrounded by numerous nationally recognized retail tenants such as KFC, McDonald’s, Taco Bell, 7-Eleven, and more. This property is located a short distance South of the Southern State Pkwy and is located 1.8 miles from the Baldwin LIRR train station.

Exterior of 1235 Grand Ave, Baldwin, NY

7. Freestanding Retail in Farmingdale, NY
Address: 34 Hempstead Tpke, Farmingdale, NY 11735
Sale Date: October 31, 2025
Sale Price: $3,500,000
Price/SF: $114

Mr 61 LLC sold this freestanding retail building in Farmingdale, NY to Multibrands 34 Hempstead Turnpike Farmingdale Real. the property was reportedly fully-leased at the time of sale.

This building consists of 30,604 square-feet, is two stories tall, and was built in 1957. The property has 195 ft of frontage on Hempstead Tpke with three curb cuts and 19 ft of frontage on Bethpage Rd. There are several different parking space options available at this property. A notable tenant at the time of sale was Dunkin’.

This property is situated East of the Bethpage State Pkwy, North of the Southern State Pkwy, and West of Merritts Rd and Fulton St. It is located a short distance from the heart of Farmingdale which has several retail spaces and amenities.

Exterior of 34 Hempstead Tpke, Farmingdale, NY

8. Storefront Retail in Port Washington, NY
Address: 118-120 Shore Rd, Port Washington, NY 11050
Sale Date: October 6, 2025
Sale Price: $3,250,000
Price/SF: $325

Musso Properties LLC sold this storefront retail building in Port Washington, NY to Philip & Linda Dejana Family Foundation.

This building consists of 10,000 square-feet, is two stories tall, was built in 1948, and later renovated in 2023. This property has 60 ft of frontage on Shore Rd and 37 on-site parking spaces.

This property is located directly across from a major shopping center with tenants such as Target, Five Below, TJ Maxx, GNC, Verizon, and more. This property is also located close to Manorhaven Beach Park & Pool.

Exterior of 118-120 Shore Rd, Port Washington, NY

9. Freestanding Retail in Rockville Centre, NY
Address: 315 Sunrise Hwy, Rockville Centre, NY 11570
Sale Date: November 17, 2025
Sale Price: $3,125,000
Price/SF: $282

Raven family Real Estate Inc sold this freestanding retail building in Rockville Centre, NY to WiseGuys Properties.

This building consists of 11,050 square-feet, is one story tall, and was built in 1948. This property has 103 ft of frontage on Sunrise Hwy and Sunrise Hwy receives high daily traffic counts of 42,010 cars per day.

This property is located in the heart of Rockville Centre surrounded by many other retail spaces and neighborhood amenities. It is located within walking distance to the Rockville Centre LIRR train station and to Park Ave which has several restaurants, a movie theatre, and more.

Exterior of 315 Sunrise Hwy, Rockville Centre, NY

10. Auto Repair in Shelter Island, NY
Address: 1 S Midway Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
Sale Date: December 18, 2025
Sale Price: $3,000,000
Price/SF: $461

Bowditch Inc sold this auto repair shop in Shelter Island, NY to an undisclosed buyer.

This building consists of 6,500 square-feet, is one story tall, and was built in 1980. There is 506 ft of frontage on Midway Rd, 108 ft of frontage on S Midway, and 134 ft of frontage on Smith St. There are 30 on-site parking spaces and the building sits on 3.66 acres of land.

This property is located near a fish shoppe, a roofing contractor, Shelter Island school, Shelter Island Public Library, and other amenities on Shelter Island.